Skip to main content
Promotional banner ad for the Penetration Testing Report Kit
Legal actionAI acted on its ownSeverity M: moderate, 2/5Alleged: one party's claim

Bombay High Court quashed Mumbai customs order citing two untraceable judgments allegedly hallucinated by AI

The Bombay High Court quashed an August 11, 2026 Order-in-Original that Mumbai's Commissioner of Customs (Import-I) passed against importer Quanta Logistics. Quanta argued the order relied on two purported Supreme Court judgments that could not be traced in legal databases and appeared to be AI hallucinations, and said copies it requested were not provided. With the customs department's consent, the court set the order aside on October 30, 2026 and directed the commissioner to pass a fresh order within eight weeks.

What the AI did

Quanta Logistics alleged that the customs authority drafted the order with the help of AI without independently applying its mind. It said the two Supreme Court judgments cited in the order, which could not be found in legal databases or law reports, appeared to be AI hallucinations. No AI tool has been named.

First reported November 7, 2026 · Added to the register November 17, 2026 · 1 source

Deployer
Commissioner of Customs (Import-I), Mumbai
Affected
Quanta Logistics
Country
India
When it happened
August 11, 2026 to October 30, 2026
First reported
November 7, 2026

What this means for you

Could this affect you?

Possibly

If your business is subject to orders from tax or customs authorities. Businesses facing decisions from tax and customs authorities that may draft orders with AI could be penalised on the basis of made-up case law, as importer Quanta Logistics allegedly was.

What to check

  • Check every judgment cited in an adverse tax or customs order against primary legal databases.
  • Request copies of any cited judgment you cannot trace.
  • Verify all citations against primary sources before relying on AI-drafted legal or regulatory documents.

Areas of your AI programme this touches

Timeline

  1. August 11, 2026Started
  2. October 30, 2026Ended
  3. November 7, 2026First reported
Every fact and its source (5)
  1. Date of the customs order2026-08-11
    “The Commissioner of Customs (Import-I), Mumbai, passed an Order-in-Original against Quanta Logistics on August 11, 2026.”[1]
  2. Regulatory gapNo CBIC instruction on verifying citations found
    “MediaNama could not find any similar instruction from the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs to customs adjudicating officers.”[1]
  3. Untraceable citations in the orderTwo purported Supreme Court judgments
    “two purported Supreme Court judgments that could not be traced in legal databases or law reports”[1]
  4. Court outcomeOrder set aside by consent on October 30, 2026
    “The court set aside the August 11, 2026, Order-in-Original by Justices M.S. Karnik and Sandesh D. Patil, with the consent of the customs department on October 30, 2026.”[1]
  5. Direction to customsFresh order within eight weeks
    “directed the commissioner to pass a fresh order within eight weeks of November 5, 2026”[1]

Sources

  1. Another customs order falls over fake judgments: How Indian courts have responded to AI hallucinations
    medianama.com · November 11, 2026

How this record is classified. Severity M (2/5): harm to individuals, or a policy breach with limited reach. Evidence: Alleged, meaning one party's claim.

The facts in At a glance and in Every fact and its source are quoted from the sources listed. The summary, What the AI did and What this means for you are written from those sources and checked against them automatically before publication. Records reflect what has been disclosed, not everything that has happened. Incidents are found through news feeds and the GDELT Project.

a promotional banner asking how ready are you for PCI DSS 4.0? With a call-to-action to get the checklist now.