CPS prosecutor cited a nonexistent case, reportedly from an AI search summary, to argue for prosecuting a child
A senior crown prosecutor at the UK's Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) cited a made-up case, 'CPS - R v J [2024] EWCA Crim 3529', while arguing in youth court for the prosecution of a boy who was 11 at the time of an alleged offence. The Guardian understands the reference came from an AI summary generated during an internet search. The prosecutor later admitted the citation was an error. Two senior high court judges called her explanation 'unsatisfactory', though the court said the fake case did not affect the outcome of the boy's challenge. The CPS said it carried out an internal review and shared learnings, including that case law must be cited from trusted legal sources.
What the AI did
An AI summary produced during an internet search reportedly contained details of a court case that does not exist, 'CPS - R v J [2024] EWCA Crim 3529', which a prosecutor then cited in youth court. It has not been reported which AI tool produced the summary.
First reported November 3, 2026 · Added to the register November 10, 2026 · 1 source
- Deployer
- Crown Prosecution Service (CPS)
- Affected
- Boy aged 11 at the time of the alleged offence
- Country
- United Kingdom (England and Wales)
- When it happened
- Not stated in the sources
- First reported
- November 3, 2026
What this means for you
Could this affect you?
If your staff use AI-generated search summaries for legal research or court filings. Any organisation whose lawyers or staff rely on AI search summaries for case law could file invented cases with a court, exposing defendants and other parties to proceedings built on false authority.
What to check
- Verify every legal authority against trusted legal databases before filing.
- Treat AI-generated search summaries as unverified.
- Audit past filings for similar errors after any incident.
Areas of your AI programme this touches
Every fact and its source (6)
- Judicial finding on explanationCalled unsatisfactory by two senior high court judges“has been called “unsatisfactory” by two senior high court judges”[1]
- Effect on outcomeDid not affect the outcome of the boy's challenge“did not affect the outcome of the boy’s challenge”[1]
- CPS responseInternal review carried out“an internal review was carried out to establish how this had occurred”[1]
- UK AI court-error tracker entries101“brings to 101 the number of entries in a UK tracker”[1]
- Fictitious case citedCPS – R v J [2024] EWCA Crim 3529“submitted a detailed reference to a case she called CPS – R v J [2024] EWCA Crim 3529”[1]
- Source of the fake citationAI summary from an internet search“the internet search delivered an AI summary which contained the fictional case details”[1]
Sources
- 'A serious failure': CPS prosecutor cites imaginary case to high court after AI searchaol.co.uk · November 3, 2026
How this record is classified. Severity M (2/5): harm to individuals, or a policy breach with limited reach. OECD level: incident, an event in which an AI system led to actual harm. Evidence: Confirmed, meaning a company, official or court statement.
The facts in At a glance and in Every fact and its source are quoted from the sources listed. The summary, What the AI did and What this means for you are written from those sources and checked against them automatically before publication. Records reflect what has been disclosed, not everything that has happened. Incidents are found through news feeds and the GDELT Project.

