Skip to main content
The state of ai impact assessment
IncidentAI acted on its ownSeverity M: moderate, 3/5Confirmed: a company, official or court statement

Google's AI Overview falsely said an Auckland anaesthetic technician had drink-driving convictions

Google's AI Overview falsely told people searching for a West Auckland anaesthetic technician that she had been convicted of drink-driving, had lied about her criminal history and had been disciplined by a tribunal. A search of her name turned up a link to an earlier Herald article about a disciplinary case that never named the practitioner involved. When questioned, the AI doubled down before admitting the cited decision did not establish a connection. The technician has no criminal convictions and remains registered and practising. She and her husband spent more than three hours on Google's online forms without success. Google told the Herald it was investigating the false association and would take action to fix the issue.

What the AI did

Google's AI Overview, an AI-written summary shown at the top of search results, told people searching for an anaesthetic technician's name that she had been convicted of drink-driving, had lied about her criminal history and had been disciplined by a tribunal. A search of her name also turned up a link to an earlier Herald article about the case, which never named the practitioner involved. When questioned, the AI first stood by the claims, then admitted the cited decision did not establish a connection.

First reported November 6, 2026 · Added to the register November 12, 2026 · 1 source

Developer
Google
Model
Google AI Overview
Affected
Tracey Melsom-Page, anaesthetic technician
Country
New Zealand
When it happened
Not stated in the sources
First reported
November 6, 2026

What this means for you

Could this affect you?

Yes

Private individuals whose names are searched on Google, especially professionals whose reputation depends on search results, can be falsely accused, and employers or colleagues who rely on AI search summaries can be misled.

What to check

  • Verify primary sources before using AI search summaries for background or reputational checks.
  • Avoid relying on AI search summaries alone when assessing a person.
  • Set up a clear route for people to report false AI-generated claims about them.
  • Give those people a way to get false claims corrected.
Every fact and its source (4)
  1. Google responseInvestigating and will fix the issue
    “Google told the Herald it was investigating the false association and would take action to fix the issue.”[1]
  2. AI admission after questioningAI admitted the cited decision did not establish a connection
    “admit the cited decision did not establish a connection”[1]
  3. Victim's actual recordNo criminal convictions; still registered and practising
    “Melsom-Page has no criminal convictions and remains a registered, practising anaesthetic technician.”[1]
  4. Attempt to contact GoogleOver three hours on online forms without success
    “Last weekend, they spent more than three hours navigating online forms and broken links, without success.”[1]

Sources

  1. 'Ruining my life': AI falsely convicts anaesthetic technician of drink-driving
    newstalkzb.co.nz · November 6, 2026

How this record is classified. Severity M (3/5): harm to individuals, or a policy breach with limited reach. OECD level: incident, an event in which an AI system led to actual harm. Evidence: Confirmed, meaning a company, official or court statement.

The facts in At a glance and in Every fact and its source are quoted from the sources listed. The summary, What the AI did and What this means for you are written from those sources and checked against them automatically before publication. Records reflect what has been disclosed, not everything that has happened. Incidents are found through news feeds and the GDELT Project.

a promotional banner asking how ready are you for PCI DSS 4.0? With a call-to-action to get the checklist now.